The Firearm Owner s Privacy Act - 1035 Words

Based upon my understanding of the United States Constitution as well as listening to the arguments brought forth by the two parties in this particular case, I see a great reason to believe that three of the four provisions of the Firearm Owner’s Privacy Act is an unconstitutional abridgment of the First Amendment. The record-keeping provision, anti-harassment provision, and the inquiry provisions are in clear violation of the First Amendment as they are content-based regulations of speech that fail strict scrutiny. However, the anti-discrimination provision of the law is constitutional as it does not regulate free speech. Syllabus: The Firearm Owner’s Privacy Act contains four provisions. The greatest problem with the three†¦show more content†¦The law, as enacted, has three provisions designed to carry-out the state of Florida’s governmental responsibility of protecting its citizens’ Second Amendment rights from being potentially infringed. Additionally, there is one provision in the law that aims to protect against the possibility that physicians might discriminate against patients or potential patients simply due to the fact that they are exercising their constitutional right of owning a firearm. However though, in creating this law, the Florida State Legislature created a content-based and viewpoint-based restriction upon physicians’ right to freedom of speech under the First Amendment. As this law imposes both a content-based and viewpoint-based restriction upon a physician’s fundamental right to free-speech specifically in order to prohibit the advocation of a specific point of view, I believe that strict scrutiny is only suitable form of judicial review for a case such as this. As was established in Ashcroft v. ACLU (2002), the government cannot impose restrictions upon the First Amendment simply because of its content. This decision was then strengthened greatly by the Supreme Court in the case of Reed v. Town of Gilbert which made the determination that laws which restrict speech â€Å"based on its communicative content†¦ are presumptivelyShow MoreRelatedMental Health Evaluations For Gun Purchase1168 Words   |  5 Pagesand destroyed families. The question is on who, or what does the blame fall on. Are the gun owners the responsible, or are the weapons themselves to blame? A solution that has been set forth concludes that in order to become a firearm owner, mental stability should be proved. Should government enforce mental health evaluations for gun purchase? Yes, to Mental Health Evaluations for the Purchase of Firearms The answer is yes, government not only has a responsibility, but a duty to the citizens ofRead MoreNra1731 Words   |  7 PagesYork state, in 1892, opposition forced it to close its first range in Long Island and relocate to New Jersey. This is dually discussed (nra.org; wikipedia.com) The NRAs began promoting shooting sports for youths in 1903 when NRA Secretary Albert S. Jones encouraged the establishment of rifle clubs at all major colleges, universities and military academies. By 1906, more than 200 boys were competing in matches. This tradition is carried forward to today, where more than one million youths participateRead MoreGun Laws And The Rights Of Free Speech1748 Words   |  7 Pagesviews on the issue. Interest groups help give people an outlet to express and act on what they believe in. States United Against Gun Violence is an interest group that has been lobbying for stricter gun laws in the U.S. to help try and prevent gun violence. This group is mainly made up and supported by people who were directly effected by gun violence, whether it be from a child accidently getting a hold of a firearm and hurting themselves or another or someone being killed in a shooting. The StatesRead MoreThe Issue Of Gun Violence1238 Words   |  5 PagesRecently, the SAFE Act, or Secure Ammunition and Firearms Enforcement Act, has sparked a large debate amongst New York residents. The law, passed January 15th, 2013, created many new restrictions for gun owners and those looking to purchase guns. Perhaps the most controversial part of the ordeal was the hasty enactment of the law. Many dispute that it is an infringement on their constitutional rights. In addition, the State doesn t have the means to enact many parts of the law. The law assumes thatRead MoreAmerica s Relationship With Guns Essay1421 Words   |  6 Pageswas urged by increasing mafia related incidents, to pass the first Federal Law to control machine gun sales, in the National Firearms Act of 1934. (History of Gun Control Legislation) In 1938, Roosevelt furthers gun control laws by, requiring interstate gun dealers to be licensed, as well as to strictly keep sales records of all transactions. Roosevelt’s National Firearms Act of 1938 also prohibited sales to those convicted of violent crimes. (History of Gun Control Legislation) In 1968, spurred byRead MoreEssay The History of Gun Control in the United States885 Words   |  4 Pages â€Å"The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.† A gun license grants a user the right to own and use a firearm. Gun-right supporters strongly oppose federally mandated licensing or registration. They see both as dangerous steps toward revoking Second Amendment rights. They say that with mandated licensing or registration, a right guaranteed by the Constitution becomes a privilege granted by the government (Doeden). The topic of gun control/rights in the United States hasRead MoreWhat Is Stop And Frisk1419 Words   |  6 Pagespossess reasonable suspicion and follow their guidelines. People should have open ideas of ways of reducing gun violence and not closing before hearing the proposals. People say that stop and frisk promote racial profiling and that it invades one’s privacy rights. Police officer are human being and make mistakes because no one is perfect in this Earth. Gun violence has been a main subject now a day, where you hear it on the news about a school shooting. Stop and frisk are an effective way to bring downRead MoreGun Control And The Rights Of A Free State1149 Words   |  5 PagesInstitute of Justice reported that in 1994, 35% of households owned 192 million firearms, with 65 million of those being handguns. 74% reported owning more than one. By 2000, the number had increased to 259 owned across the nation and 294 million by 2007. Retail prices vary from $75 to $1500 for a typical handgun. A gun is used in a homicide 3.2 times per 100,000 people per the FBI Crime Reports of 2011. In 2009, firearm fatalities numbered 11,826 homicides, 18,735 suicides, 554 accidental shootingsRead MoreCivil Liberties And The American Dream1739 Words   |  7 Pagesthat would have to rapidly protect themselves from men rebelling against the militia. The Third Amendment was strictly enforced to give the citi zens comfort and peace in their American homes. It states that a government official is to give citizens privacy unless demanded to interrupt the peace. Finally, the last amendment that protects basic freedoms would be recognized as the Fourth Amendment. This amendment placed restrictions on unlawful search and seizures of American’s property. Although theseRead MoreGun Control Essay1219 Words   |  5 Pagesthe epidemic of gun violence that is facing this nation today. There is evidence to support that many guns used for illegal activities are obtained by illegal means anyway, making laws to restrict the purchase of said guns ineffective at keeping firearms out of criminals hands. Evidence also supports the statements that guns are used in defense more often than not, that the age old statistic that â€Å"13† children die each day by guns is inaccurate, and that there are numbers that show the direct relationship